There are two different lip balm (and lotion) formulas for you to choose from. The red label is the original formula and the orange label is the mango butter formula. (In case you're wondering, the mango butter formula uses mango butter but it does not smell like mangoes).
So which one is better?
Neither. They’re just different.
Over the years we've had some people unable to use the red label formula because they were allergic to one of the ingredients. As a result, we created the orange label formula to give people with allergies an option. Both formulas do contain cocoa butter and beeswax because we couldn't get the consistency right without them. Sorry if you're allergic to either of those ingredients!
So what's the difference between them other than ingredients?
The red label lip balms have a higher melting point and feel a little more “solid”. The orange label lip balms have a lower melting point and feel a little more “slippery” or "slick" (in a good way).
Both formulas are excellent and we recommend that over time you try them both to see which one you prefer.
Here are the ingredients in each one:
Red Label Lip Balm (Unscented): Soybean oil; Beeswax; Sunflower oil; Cocoa butter; Shea butter; Vitamin E.
Orange Label Lip Balm (Unscented): Sweet almond oil; Coconut oil; Beeswax; Avocado oil; Cocoa Butter; Mango Butter.